How to Pick the Perfect Birthdays Cake

How to Pick the Perfect Birthdays Cake

How to Pick the Perfect Birthdays Cake

Birthdays are special – every person has their own special day unless you have a twin, or triplet, etc.  A birthdays cake just makes that day even more special when you have others help celebrate– so choosing the right cake is important.

Here are 4 tips to help get you started:

How to Pick the Perfect Birthday Cake Size: The number of people you plan to serve will determine the size cake you need – whether you buy it or make it.

Budget:  Depending on what type of cake and where you buy it, a birthday cake can get expensive. Many people choose to make birthday cakes for their loved ones, which is perfectly fine. Have fun!

Bakery: If ordering a cake, visit a few bakeries, then decide. Check out the baker and their reputation –ask friends, family, co-workers for their recommendations.

How to Pick the Perfect Birthday Cake Type and Flavor: Depending on the age of the person’s whose birthday is being celebrated, the type of cake you order should be appropriate. Children like character cakes and ice cream cakes while young adults like themed cakes.  Mature adults seem to prefer fruit-filled and ice cream cakes as well.  Some just like the good old-fashioned birthday cake with white icing and well-wishes.

When in doubt, ask the birthday boy or girl what they would like – chocolate is always a big hit! And don’t forget the ice cream!

Why Do We Love Happy Birthday Cakes So Much

What is it about Birthday Cake that gets everyone so excited? Parties can be fun, however, it doesn’t really get going full blast until those candles are blown out and the cake is cut. It’s as if the party is just an excuse for champagne and birthday cake if you ask me.

Everyone has their favorite part of the birthday cake.

For instance, are you a devoted icing gal? Or, are you the kind of person who lives for the spongy middle? Have you been known to obsess over the middle part, slowly eating the filling between the fluffy cake layers? Do you long to be the one to grab a decorative cookie or macaron off the top and eat it quickly so no one will notice… and try to do it again? Have you felt the shame of stealing a macaron from a child’s hands and then not admitting it when they cry out that you took it? Maybe that’s just me??

So, why do we love birthday cake so much? 

Let’s take a look at where they came from to get some clues…

Cakes for birthdays are believed to have originated in Germany in the 1400s. They were almost exclusively for the wealthy, as they were the only ones to afford such luxuries back then. But the cakes then are absolutely nothing like the ones we have now- and thankfully so! Most were simple sweetened bread dough and were made out of coarse and plain tasting ingredients. So, most likely you’d say, “No thanks!” to second helpings. The earliest known birthday cakes were in the shape of the moon and later developed into the more common round shapes we know and love today.


Cakes developed through the years and different cultures to include.

The best part: the icing and decorations that make each cake unique. In medieval times, thimbles and coins and were poured and then baked into the batter. Can you imagine biting down on one of them? It’s not such a happy birthday when you’re spending it at the dentist. This brings a whole new meaning to a “surprise party”.  It was thought that the person who bit into the coin would get rich, while the unfortunate person who took a bite of the thimble would never get married. Cue a sad, slow version of “Happy Birthday” here. Yeah, not so much a ‘happy birthday’ but more like a, “You may die an old maid, but here’s some cake and sorry about your tooth”, birthday.

The rise of the birthday cake mix

With the Industrial Revolution came the invention of the dry baking mixes that were originally promoted for their convenience. England made the first known dry cake mix, a custard powder, which hit the markets in the 1840s. A few years later in the 1890s, pancake mixes became available to the public. It wasn’t until the 1920s that the mixes you’re familiar with for at-home birthday cakes first came onto the scene and rose to popularity.

The famous Betty Crocker/General Mills combo hit mega-fame in the 1940s and still remains popular today! However, the look was super simple and the taste? Well, let’s just say you can tell it came from a box and could have possibly been made in the 1950s.

Birthday Cakes Are A Part Of Us


As the saying goes, “We’ve come a long way, baby!” Now you can get one of a kind, customizable, bespoke and super creative cakes upon request- and you don’t have to be German royalty to do so. The fun thing about birthday cakes is that you can make it as specific for that person who’s celebrating getting a year older as you want! If you know someone who can’t stop pulling into a burger joint to get their fast food fix on- then check out the Triple Decker Fast Food Cake!

Happy Birthday Cakes - Triple Decker Fast Food Cake

You can’t go wrong with a fudge brownie ‘meat’ patty sandwiched between sesame-doughnut buns, then throw on some chocolate cheese and buttercream lettuce leaves, and don’t forget the ganache mustard and ketchup! If they’re more of a fried chicken fan, they won’t be left out with the chicken leg made of fudgy brownie and a chocolate-covered biscuit with a popcorn bone and coated in what else? Why cookie crumbs, duh.

If your friend is totally trippin’ out that they’re getting more greys! then it seems a slice of the LSD Cake is in order!

Way better than the famous hallucinogen of the 60s, this cake will take you to new heights in just one bite! It’s silly and fun and has so many colors in it; you may think you’re in an alternate Universe, man.

Perfect Birthdays Cake

So now we know how deeply birthday cakes are a part of us! It’s no wonder it doesn’t feel like a celebration unless there’s birthday cake. The tradition has been around for a long time, and it’s ever-growing and ever-expanding in creativity, flavors, and fun! Next time you blow out those candles, remember to make a wish and be grateful you won’t bite down on a thimble.

Happy Birthday!